
Delhi High Court dismissed appeals seeking the death penalty for Delhi Police Head Constable Ajay Kumar Tomar for a 2011 robbery-cum-double murder incident, upholding his life term handed down by a trial court.
A bench of Justices Navin Chawla and Ravinder Dudeja dismissed the appeals against his conviction, filed by Tomar as well as by the Delhi government and the victim’s family member, Harvinder Singh, son of the slain Amarjeet Singh Chadha, who had filed the enhancement pleas.
It affirmed the Delhi’s Tis Hazari trial court’s December 24, 2021 conviction under IPC Sections 302 (murder) and 397 (robbery or dacoity with attempt to cause death or grievous hurt) and the Arms Act, and the May 13, 2022 sentence of life imprisonment (for each murder) and 10 years (rigorous imprisonment) with a fine of Rs 50,000 under Arms Act Section 27.
Why Breach of Public Trust Did Not Merit Hanging
While the prosecution and Amarjeet’s son pressed for the death penalty for the double murder committed by firearms by a policeman, the High Court said the misuse of “position of trust” in an unpardonable offence by a person entrusted with safeguarding the lives of citizens was acknowledged. However, it refused to straightaway use double deaths or the fact that Tomar was a policeman to send him to the gallows.
“The factum of commission of two murders by the appellant…though a serious aggravating factor, cannot automatically lead to the conclusion that the sentence of death has to be the outcome in such cases,” the High Court said, adding that violation of the public’s trust by a policeman “alone cannot be the ground to award a death sentence”. The court found no “exceptional brutality…extraordinary depravity” or evidence to suggest that Tomar is “not capable of reformation or rehabilitation” on the examination of the record. And hence, it was not a case of “rarest of rare”.
The 2011 Shootings and Corroborated Evidence
On September 24, 2011, Tomar, who was in a Sub-Inspector’s uniform with a fake ID card of SI Ajay Kumar Gupta, shot Amarjeet Singh Chadha thrice on SPM Marg. He robbed him of his gold chains. Moments later, as he was being chased on a bike by HC Surender, Tomar opened fire at them and shot Sunny in the neck. While Amarjeet Singh was declared brought dead at Tirath Ram Hospital the same night, Sunny died two days later.
After jumping off the flyover in his escape bid, Tomar was arrested. The police recovered two pistols and three broken gold chains with three lockets. The court rejected Tomar’s defence, saying he took direct aim at Sunny and didn’t even fire in the air. It was based on eyewitness testimony coupled with a postmortem report, ballistic examination, fingerprints, and empty cartridges recovered from Tomar’s Santro car. All of which were sufficient to ignore minor lapses during the investigation.