Why Demands to Ban Ramayana Over Ravana’s Portrayal Make Zero Sense

16 days after Nitesh Tiwari’s Ramayana: Rise of a Legend was released in theatres on November 5, the Vishwa Hindu Parishad (VHP) suddenly asked that the film be removed from cinemas. On Saturday, 21 November, VHP general secretary Bajrang Lal Bagra and VHP international president Alok Kumar called for the film to be taken off theatres by withdrawing the U certificate issued by the Central Board of Film Certification. Kumar demanded an immediate stop to its screening by the CBFC. In the footsteps of the Hindu Janajagruti Samiti and Sanatan Sanstha, who raised similar objections days ago in Mumbai. Kumar told PTI that the makers portrayed Yash’s Ravana as “liberator of Dalits, the exploited and the deprived”.

It’s almost a circus act to ask for a certified film to be yanked out of cinemas after the Indian audience has provided it with ₹1,070 crore in box office earnings (and ₹1,600+ globally). When millions of Hindu cinegoers have purchased tickets and filled up cinema theatres without falling for the crisis of faith claimed by the VHP leaders. The call for a retrospective ban isn’t defence of religion. Rather, an attempt to treat adults buying tickets as children who require ideological tutelage.

Judging Half a Story as Ideological Subversion

Most objections about the backstory of Ravana, detailing the sufferings of his clan and the vehement penance to Brahma, ignore the elementary two-fold screenwriting. This adaptation by Nitesh Tiwari and co-writer Shridhar Raghavan unfolds in two parts. Actor Anupam Kher (voicing Jatayu) said in The Hollywood Reporter India. In commercial cinema, the first part builds a strong antagonist so the climax defeat has maximum impact. Kher gave examples like Sholay and Karma. The Ram played by Ranbir Kapoor still has key showdowns with Vali, Meghnad and Ravana left in Part Two of the movie.

Bagra and actor Nitish Bharadwaj of Mahabharat fame equally voice their outcry over the pace and gaps left out. Bagra criticised the makers for not showing Ahalya’s redemption and Nishadraj Guha. He also complained that Kevat wasn’t shown, thus reducing Ram’s purpose in life to a vendetta for abducting Sita. Bharadwaj said Ram in the movie “seemed a minuscule human being, a normal human being”. Ramayana by Valmiki is 24,000 Sanskrit shlokas in 7 books. Ramanand Sagar required 78 episodes of a television show to present it. Selective trimming of subplots to fit a 3-hour 15-minute theatrical release seems not sacrilegious but editing.

Self-Appointed Text Police Who Missed the Text

The attempt to ban the movie is in shreds when the most vocal ban brigade resorts to holy books. HJS heads Sunil Ghanwat and Manoj Solanki, in their Mumbai press conference, claimed the movie makers are pursuing a “Communist agenda”. They advised Hindus to boycott the movie. HJS leaders threatened nationwide street protests if saints and scholars are not allowed to view Part Two of the movie before it is shown. The HJS leaders had also cited these as among the misrepresentations of Valmiki’s Ramayana by Nitesh Tiwari. The movie failed to show Ravana attempting Shiva’s bow and failing during Sita’s swayamvar.

There is no mention of Ravana in Valmiki’s Ramayana attempting to lift Shiva’s bow in the swayamvar of Sita. In Valmiki’s Bala Kanda and Ayodhya Kanda, there is no mention of Ravana being among the prospective grooms in Mithila. It’s Tulsidas’s Ramcharitmanas that mentions his presence. Later regional renditions and TV shows also have the episode where he tries and fails to lift the bow. Ramayana, which has been creatively told in 300 different versions, doesn’t need pre-screening veto units. Please at least study the book you want to defend in case of objections to censorship from the CBFC.

Leave a Reply